Experimental Validation of a Multi Model PI Controller for a Non Linear Hybrid System in LabVIEW

M.Kalyan Chakravarthi, Nithya Venkatesan


In this paper a real time Single Spherical Tank Liquid Level System (SSTLLS) has been chosen for investigation. This paper describes the design and development of a Multi Model PI Controller (MMPIC) using classical controller tuning techniques for a single spherical nonlinear tank system. System identification of these different regions of nonlinear process are done using black box modeling, which is identified to be nonlinear and approximated to be a First Order Plus Dead Time (FOPDT) model. A proportional and integral controller is designed using LabVIEW and Chen-Hrones-Reswick (CHR), Zhuang-Atherton (ZA), and Skogestad’s Internal Model Controller (SIMC) tuning methods are implemented in real time. The paper provides the details about the data acquisition unit, shows the implementation of the controller, and comparision of the results of PI tuning methods used for an MMPI Controller.


User Interface (GUI), PI Controller, Chen-Hrones-Reswick (CHR), Zhuang-Atherton (ZA), and Skogestad’s Internal Model Controller (SIMC), LabVIEW

Full Text:



Biegler,L.T., and Rawlings,J.B.,1991,”Optimization approaches to nonlinear model predictive control”, In chemical process control,CPCIV,pp.543-571,Austin,TX.

Kravaris,C.,and Arkun,Y.,1991, ”Geometric nonlinear control-An Overview”, International journal of chemical process control,CPCIV,pp.477-515,Austin,TX,1991.

Raich,A.,Wu,X.,and Cinar,A.,1991, ”Approximate dynamic models for chemical processes: A comparative study of neural networks and nonlinear time series modeling techniques”.,AIChE Conference,Los Angeles,CA.

George,K.I.,Boa-gang Hu.,and Raymand,1999,”Analysis of direct action fuzzy PID controller structures”, IEEE Trans.on SMC,29(3),pp.371-388.

Ziegler J.G..,and Nicolas N.B.,1942,”Optimum settings for automatic controllers”, Transactions of ASME,64,pp.759-768.

Zhuang.M., and Atherton.D.P.,1993, ”Automatic tuning of optimum PID controllers, Proceedings of IEEE 140(3),pp.216-224.

Sung S.W.,Lee.O. J.,Lee I..B.,Lee.J,and Yi I..B,1996,”Automatic tuning of PID controller using second order plus dead time delay model”, Journal of Chemical Engineering of Japan, 29(6),pp991-999.

Astrom,K.J.,and Hagglund,T.,1984,”Automatic tuning of simple regulators with specifications on phase and amplitude margins,Automatica,20(5),pp.645-651.

Cohen G.H.,Coon G.A.,1953,”Theoritical consideration of retarted control”.Transactions of ASME,75,pp 827-834.

Hang C.C.,and Astrom K.J.,Ho W.k.,1991,”Refinements of the Ziegler Nicolas tuning formula”,Proc IEE Control Theory App,138,pp.111-118.

Garcia C.E.,and Morari M.,2000,”Internal model control:1.A unifying review and some new results,1 &EC Process Des.and Dev.,21(2),pp.308-323.

Rivera D.E.,Morari M,and Skogested S.,1986,Internal Model Control for PID controller Design,I.&E.C. Process Des.and Dev.,25(1),pp.22-265.

Astrom,K.J.,and Hagglund,1996,Automatic Tuning of PID Controllers”,The Control Handbook,CRC Press,Florida,pp817-826.

Depaor.A.M,andO’Malley M.,1989,:Controllers Of Ziegler Nicolas type for unstable Processes”,Int.J.Control,49,pp.1273-1284.

S.Nithya,N.Sivakumaran,T.Balasubramanian,N.Anantharaman,2008,”Model based controller design for a spherical tank process in real time”, IJSSST Vol.9 No.4.

Naresh N. Nandola, Sharad Bharatiya, “A multiple model approach for predictive control of nonlinear hybrid systems” , Journal of process control, vol.18 (2008), pp. 131-148.

K.Hari Krishna, J.Satheesh Kumar and Mahaboob Shaik, “Design and development of model based controller for a spherical tank” , International journal of current engineering and technology, Vol.2, No.4(Dec. 2012) ,pp 374-376.

D.DineshKumar , B.Meenakshipriya, “Design and implementation of non linear system using gain scheduled PI controller”,Procedia engineering, Vol.38 (2012) ,pp 3105-3112.

K.Sundaravadivu, K.Saravanan, “Design of fractional order PID Controller for liquid level control of spherical tank”, European journal of Scientific Research, vol.84 no.3 (2012),pp.345-353.

M.Kalyan Chakravarthi, Nithya Venkatesan,“LabVIEW Based Tuning Of PI Controllers For A Real Time Non Linear Process”, Journal of Theoretical and Applied Information Technology,Volume 68, Number 3,October 2014, pp579-585.

M.Kalyan Chakravarthi,Pannem.K.Vinay,Nithya Venkatesan,” Real Time Implementation of Gain Scheduled Controller Design for Higher Order Nonlinear System Using LabVIEW” , International Journal of Engineering and Technology, Volume 6 No 5 Oct-Nov 2014.pp.2031-2038.

Deepanshu Soni , Mohit Gagrani ,Ashwin Rathore ,M. Kalyan Chakravarthi,” Study of Different Controller’s Performance for a Real Time Non-Linear System” International Journal of Advancements in Electronics and Electrical Engineering, ISSN 2319-7498, Volume 3 : Issue 3,September,2014.pp.10-14.

G.S.Cheng and J.C.Hung,J.C. “A least-squares based self tuning of PID Controller”, Proc. IEEE South East Conference, North Carolina,1985,pp.325-332.

E.S.Prabhu and M.Chidambaram.,”Robust control of a distillation coloumn by method of inequalities” Indian Chen.Engr. Vol 37,pp.181-187,1991.

K.R.Sundaresan .and R.R.Krishnaswamy,“Estimation of time delay,Time constant parameters inTime, Frequency and Laplace Domains” ,Can.J.Chem.Eng, Vol. 56,.257 . 1978

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.12928/telkomnika.v13i2.1322

Article Metrics

Abstract view : 239 times
PDF - 237 times


Copyright (c) 2019 Universitas Ahmad Dahlan

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

TELKOMNIKA Telecommunication, Computing, Electronics and Control
ISSN: 1693-6930, e-ISSN: 2302-9293
Universitas Ahmad Dahlan, 4th Campus, 9th Floor, LPPI Room
Jl. Ringroad Selatan, Kragilan, Tamanan, Banguntapan, Bantul, Yogyakarta, Indonesia 55191
Phone: +62 (274) 563515, 511830, 379418, 371120 ext. 4902, Fax: +62 274 564604

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.